Thursday, September 6, 2018

How the "New City" Question will appear on the November 6, 2018 Ballot

Here it is:

New Municipality in Northeast Miami-Dade

Shall the Miami-Dade County Board of County Commissioners be authorized to create a new municipality in the area of northeast Miami-Dade with the following outermost boundaries?
Northern boundary: County line
Eastern boundary: City limits of Aventura (Biscayne Blvd.)
Southern boundary: City limits of North Miami Beach
Western boundary: Interstate 95
Yes

No


Commentary (oh, you knew there'd be some):
The northern, western and southern boundaries all make sense, but the critical Eastern boundary - why?

The NE MAC negotiated a "Conceptual Agreement" with the County, where the Eastern boundary was defined as "Dixie Highway/Biscayne Boulevard".  I was part of the NE MAC when this agreement was being negotiated, but not when it was finalized.  Prior to it being finalized, I had asked that the boundary be defined as "City limits of Aventura" (like the southern boundary made reference to the city limits of NMB).  You can find a copy of the conceptual agreement here (at Exhibit 5), and see my advice was not heeded.

The actual resolution passed by the NE MAC also defined the Eastern boundary in the 2nd WHEREAS clause as "Dixie Highway/Biscayne Boulevard" [you can find this resolution as Exhibit 4 in the link above]

In September 26, 2017 in a memo from Jorge Fernandez to the Planning Advisory Board (who met that same day to decide on whether to adopt the NE MAC's recommendation and put the issue of a new city to a vote by residents), Fernandez corrected the Eastern boundary as "the City of Aventura to the east" (because what I'd said months earlier had finally been understood: the prior language lacked specificity, and Biscayne Blvd. really isn't the boundary at ANY point - you can see this plain as day in the graphic from my VERY FIRST WoA post, which you can find here).

On June 5, 2018, the Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners ("BCC") considered Resolution R-576-18 (which you can find about 3/4 through the document here).  The very TITLE of the resolution describes the eastern boundary as "THE CITY LIMITS OF THE CITY OF AVENTURA TO THE EAST" (and repeats the same language in the second 'whereas' clause of the resolution).  Section 3 of this resolution then goes into extremely detailed 'metes and bounds' (a legal term) description of the proposed new city boundaries.

So why did the ballot question muddy the issue that took so long to resolve, by throwing in the words "(Biscayne Blvd.)" after the sufficiently clear "City limits of Aventura"?  Especially when there is no point on the proposed eastern boundary that even TOUCHES Biscayne Blvd (see: https://www.miamidade.gov/incorporationandannexation/library/maps/northeast-dade.pdf).

I don't know the answer, but because the ballot language above is the exact language passed by the BCC (see page 9 of the resolution), voters will have to live with it.

Oh: and in case you were wondering, the western boundary of Aventura (and therefore the eastern boundary of the 'new city') is actually the FEC railroad tracks (that's not 100% accurate for the entire boundary, but it's a more useful 'rule of thumb' than Biscayne Blvd., which is just completely inaccurate).



Thursday, August 30, 2018

Naming a New City: Factors to Consider

A recent study evaluated correlations between neighborhood name and things like home value and household income.  You can read the full report here.

In prior posts, I speculated that property values would increase if the area were annexed by Aventura, and decrease if the area were annexed by North Miami Beach, because of the premium/stigma (collectively, the "baggage") associated with those names.

Annexation options have evaporated since those posts, and this year the focus is exclusively on incorporation of a new city, an issue which appears on the November general election ballot.

If it passes (which is nowhere near certain), the decision to create a new city would create an opportunity to devise a city name that might increase (or at least not diminish) home values.

One interesting note from the Porch.com study: the household income numbers already correlate to several of our neighborhood names:


Oak Forest contains the #4 "Oaks" and #9 "Forest"
Highland Lakes contains the #6 "Highland"
Sorry Sky Lake and Enchanted Lake.

The more important list is "Highest Home Values" (bottom part of the graphic).  In the top 10, only "Highland Gardens" has a word that makes the list ("Gardens," coming in at #10).

So in response to the oft-asked question "what should we call the new city?", I would propose:
"Island Beach Harbor Hills Village"
;)

This blog always refers to the potential new city as "West Aventura," but a compromise incorporating elements from the names of existing communities "Highland Gardens" and "Oak Forest" could be simply "Highland Oaks," which could explain how the area's original schools came to be named, decades ago ("Virginia A. Boone Highland Oaks Elementary" and "Highland Oaks Middle" respectively).

Wednesday, August 29, 2018

Special Taxing Districts (if you live in a gated community "West of Aventura" - read)

This is an edited letter I sent to the NE MAC security leads - people who, like me, volunteer to serve as a liason between the community and the County department that manages the guard houses, which you see on your tax bill each year (the preliminary one just went out this weekend).  

As you'd imagine, there is a lot of 'behind the scenes' with these districts, and sometimes a district has no idea what is going on when their rate goes up by hundreds of dollars.  Residents just shrug and pay their tax bill.  But huge increases in recent years got a lot of people in our area very interested, and thankfully we now have a system with much more oversight and accountability.  

One product of this oversight was the switch by many districts (first Highland Lakes/Gardens, then Coventry, and now Oak Forest and Enchanted) to a new provider (Kent Security) that offered significant savings and cameras at the guard gates: more for less (see last blog post for more on this).  But even with that kind of 'victory,' no community can afford to rest on its laurels.

So here is a peek 'behind the curtain' about issues discussed among security leads for the guard gates and the area's single roving patrol (where I am the lead):

* * *

"When I didn't receive a 'proposed notice of rate' from Sue Torano [our contact within the County] this year for my district (Oak Forest Roving), I found out [the lead in Highland Lakes/Gardens] got his in May, so I wrote to get rates, and then budgets.  Subsequently, I just got my property tax bill in the mailbox, and was a little astounded to see the roving patrol (who had huge coverage holes this year) was basically the same cost as last year (only $30 less).  So I reviewed tons of material and had 1.5hr talk with Sue.  Here's the summary, which applies to ALL security Special Taxing Districts ("STDs"):

"1. Torano hasn't historically emailed leads if there is NO fee increase.  Highland Lakes had a small increase, so [their lead] was emailed.  Oak Forest/Enchanted had a decrease, so no email.  But because it is always important to be informed, I asked, and Sue agreed, to send emails every year REGARDLESS of direction of upcoming fees.  In Oak Forest's case, we really needed to see the notice, because the amount of the decrease for roving was not at all what we'd been told to expect (more on that below).

"2. The financials she sent for Oak Forest/Enchanted gates showed only a slight decrease (hence, no email).  I expected a larger one due to the transition to Kent for those 2 districts (saving $41K), but because the transition was 5/12/18, it was too late to budget for - the 2019 budgets actually contemplate the higher USSA rates (approx $402K), not Kent (approx $361)!

"3. I asked 'if the budget assumed USSA, not Kent, then why did the rate go down at all - shouldn't it have gone UP?'  The confusing answer, was that big carry-forwards were the main reason (more on that below).

"4. RESERVES.  Oak Forest gate for some reason has a whopping $84,100 contingency reserve - about 17% of budget, even though the goal is supposed to be 10%!  Crazy!  I said that for 2020, that needs to be brought back down to 10%, especially since the switch to Kent from USSA is going to save about $40,000, ON TOP OF that huge reserve.  So Oak's Gate should see a big drop next year.  If Oak Forest ever contemplated automating one of it's 2 gates (which would presumably involve some capital costs), this might be a good time to consider that, as the surplus would absorb a lot of the cost (and thereafter Oak Forest could be saving $200,000/year in guard costs).

"5. Sue [Torano] agreed to reach out to us in the SPRING next year to discuss budgets, so we can be more proactive, not RE-active.  I'm upset about the roving patrol rate not going down a ton (see #8 below), and I could have had that conversation MONTHS ago and saved the roving people like myself some grief (and money!).

"6. On Enchanted Lake, I compared the financials with Oak Forest going back several years.  I noted my amazement that Enchanted had paid $5300-7100 for 'landscaping' up until 2017, when that number went to ZERO.  For 2018 it is again ZERO, because Enchanted HAS NO LANDSCAPING!  So basically Enchanted Lake, for years, was getting f***ed, because people were 'pretending' to mow lawns, and supervisors were 'pretending' to verify the work, when there was never any work TO do.  Astounding.  Read your budgets!

"7. Signs: yeah, they were expensive.  Budgeted at $5000/pair and came in closer to $4000 EACH.  Very upsetting.  Won't need to be done again any time soon I hope, and yet if we incorporate, would we want those signs to have a city name on them?  Ugh.  Very depressing.  

"8. Oak Roving: FHP missed a whole month after the hurricane, and turned in 50% time sheets other months, so how on earth did the rate only drop $30 on my 2019 tax notice?  Where is the money?  Well the answer is (i) the contingency reserve for that district needs to be even lower than the 10% for the gates - maybe 5%; (ii) the money is still 'in the district'; didn't go elsewhere (which I have trouble believing); and (iii) the projections for 2018 are WAY off.  She calculated them on the spot and we are looking at tens of thousands less than the already-reduced budget.  Since they used wrong assumptions for this year, they projected wrong assumptions also!  Not only that: the budget for 2019 indicated $1195/household, but for some insane reason the number they submitted to the county to approve was $1329!  This is exactly why I wish I'd received a notice of the price (even if it's a decrease), so I could have gone to the meeting and screamed it down.  I told Sue that when it comes to this particular district, OPTICS MATTER - we all expected a decrease, we aren't getting one, we need to see one next year.  A big one.

"9. Oak Roving switch to MDPD: MDPD was really interested, got Sally Heyman to amend the ordinance, then found themselves in a position where they can't even figure out a way to move forward: the county can't contract with itself (Torano says), and MDPD would need someone from the county 'sign off' at the start of each shift, which is impossible.  So anyone with interest in this option: basically forget it (it was more expensive anyway).

"10. Coventry: Sue responded to a lot of my complaints by saying that Coventry also experienced some concerns about it's budget (which I don't have to be able to comment on), and I'm copying [Coventry Lead] to see if he has other thoughts to share on what sounds like a similar experience.

"11. Fixed costs may be going up: After a recent vote (2016?), STDs located within a CITY are able to transfer control from the County (like us), to their city (which we can't do, being unincorporated).  Sue said many districts are taken advantage of this, and spreading the same costs across fewer districts means we could see increases even if nothing else changes.  That sucks.  This may be one reason to incorporate a new city and manage our own districts to reduce costs (a single 2-gate district has a 4-year average of about $35K in County Overhead baked-in, so between our 6 districts... that's a job I'd apply for).

"Conclusion: Rates didn't drop enough this year, possibly to build a 'cushion' for future fixed-cost increases (as more districts defect to city-management), but we should start reviewing earlier in the cycle next spring to ensure rates drop as they should (and reserves will be set at more reasonable levels) at least in the short-term.  The 'landscaping' charges in Enchanted alone justify active review, and share experience like in this email.  When I'm notified in the Spring of discussions, I'll make sure other leads are in the loop."

Thursday, April 5, 2018

How A Simple Request can save a Neighborhood $40,000 per year

Subtitle: Complacency is Costly!

We all live in "special taxing district," but some of us live in more of them than others.  You can tell how many you live in by looking at your property tax bill or notice - the "Non-Ad Valorem Assessments" category lists them, such as "Lighting District," "Solid Waste," and "Guard Gate."  Another clue is if you drive past/through a guard gate on your way home every day.

Even though the "Lighting District" comes to only $67.66 on my tax bill - not a huge deal - one local resident did some digging and found out that he was paying for lights that didn't exist in his community.  This anecdote is evidence of inefficiencies in the system generally, which in the aggregate could represent enormous inequities.  I'm not an expert in street lighting districts, but I have become one with respect to the Guard Districts (guard-gates and/or roving patrol).

Many of the guardhouse districts were created in the 1990s, possibly due to a wave of crime at that time (in my own neighborhood, there are stories of regular armed robberies that precipitated closing off streets and limiting access to 2 roads with guard gates).

At that time, a company called 50 State managed to secure the lion's share of the guard gate contracts, despite the fact that they were not the lowest bidder, raising the prospect of some sort of corruption.  If there was some kind of bribe, it was worth it, because the sweet deal for 50 State endured for decades: once a special taxing district was formed, communities were rarely organized well enough to provide much (if any) oversight of those districts: residents just accepted the fact that there was a line on their tax bill for services they agreed to by simply living in the community.

In 2016 many of the guard gates experienced a huge spike on the tax bill.  This resulted from the diligence of a small gated community called Biscayne Point.  The new HOA President of that district started doing some digging, raised his findings with the then-Chief of Special Taxing Districts (Don Tock), and uncovered massive accounting deficiencies.  Biscayne Point had believed it was running a respectable surplus, but uncovered a large DEFICIT that resulted in a 'catch-up' payment that appeared not only in Biscayne Point, but on the bills of residents in ALL gated communities, including West of Aventura ("WoA") communities like Highland Lakes, Highland Gardens, Oak Forest, Enchanted Lake and Coventry.  It was a very unwelcome surprise.

The tax hikes were sufficiently alarming to shake some areas out of their long slumber, and demand more accountability.  The STD division was reorganized (and is now part of the Parks Department), a new Chief was appointed (Mike Bauman), and the flow of information from the County to communities began in earnest.

One of the most interesting pieces of information I received was a 'master budget' showing a long list of gated communities and the rates each pays for the same services:


In the graphic, the 5 "WoA" guard districts are highlighted.

This image is actually of 2018 rates, not the 2016-17 ones I first requested, but these financial tables led to an amazing discovery: until recently, all WoA Communities were receiving services under a 1994 Contract with 50 State, which was acquired by US Security Associates ("USSA") a few years ago.  That company was charging the County (who then charged applicable residents) $201,163 per gate for services (batch at the top of the graphic).  The exact same services were available from Kent Security for $184,981 per gate (batch at the bottom of the graphic), so for a 2-gate community, the difference was over $41,000 per YEAR!

"APPLES TO APPLES"
Skeptical readers may guess that USSA provides superior services or better guards that are worth the premium.  NOPE!  The situation here is exceedingly rare in that it is truly 'apples to apples' because when a community switches from one provider to another, the same guards can be hired by the new provider, making the transition largely undetectable (except for the badge on the guard's uniform).  Even the pay the guard receives stays the same, because becoming approved by the County involves assenting to cost of living and wage requirements that are the same.

One of the first communities to catch on to all this was Highland Lakes/Highland Gardens, where their county liaison Marc Hurwitz was (and is) also President of the larger area HOA.  Hurwitz organized those 2 gated communities sufficiently to formally request a provider change to Kent.  In addition to the $40,000++ cost savings, satisfaction levels actually went UP!  This may be due to the fact that Kent is based locally, whereas USSA is based in Marietta Georgia, and run more for profit than for quality control and customer service.

... AND MORE: CAMERAS
Kent was also able to overcome a challenge that had existed for years: getting CAMERAS installed at the gates to reinforce the work of the guard, provide a tool for police investigating area crimes, and simply to serve as a visible deterrent to crime.  In several other districts (Biscayne Bay, Gables by the Sea), frustrated residents simply installed cameras themselves, but one district (Sans Souci) discovered a disastrous downside to doing this: when a resident requested footage that was not deliverEd, the HOA found itself party to a lawsuit that went on for years and cost thousands to defend.

Another Gate district - Keystone Point - went a different direction: they set up a entirely new and separate taxing district in order to get the cameras through the County!  This "solution" ended up being such a costly and inefficient nightmare, that the County now actively discourages replicating this model.

By taking ownership of the CCTV/Camera issue, Kent both avoids the inefficiencies of the County, and at the same time protects residents and HOAs from the liability and risk (and maintenance and upkeep) associated with having control.

THE BALANCE IS SHIFTING
This is just speculation, but I think 50 State sensed there was trouble brewing around it's decades-long grip on the special taxing districts, and it chose to bail out by selling to USSA, rather than see its model begin to implode starting in 2016.  By 2017, Highland Lakes and Highland Gardens had both moved in the above graphic from the "USSA" batch of contracts at the top of the image, to the "Kent Security Services" batch of contracts at the bottom of the image (all WoA communities are highlighted in the table so you can find them easily).

And even the 2018 graphic is out of date, because in December 2017, Coventry (G-103) joined Highland Lakes/Highland Gardens in transitioning to Kent.  With close to 30 homes in Coventry, residents there will save over $600 per year for the exact same services (same gate, same guards) as they had with USSA.

Now Oak Forest and Enchanted Lake have also formed security committees to better oversee services and communicate with residents, and also to request transition to Kent to save about $250/year per residence (enough to buy a Ring doorbell after 1 year, or a private CCTV after 2 years, both of which would vastly improve personal security).  Those savings are not one-time; they accrue year after year after year, and all just for knowing enough to ASK the county for a provider change.

The moral of the story: get organized, ask questions and be an informed consumer, and you can break dynastic contracts with unmotivated providers and improve things not just for yourself, but for your community.

Tuesday, December 5, 2017

The "Theft" of a 1.65 acre parcel of prime land "WoA" for Just $255K

I'd first heard that a huge parcel of land on NE 199th had sold to a developer "for a song" on Nextdoor.  It seemed like the kind of story that couldn't be true, so I had to do some digging to debunk it.

The Country records did confirm a sale to "House 55, LLC", and a search of Florida Records did lead me to discover that this company was owned by a man named Djmal, who also appeared to hold titles with several real estate development entities.

I was intrigued enough to travel way south to FDOT offices in Kendall to review the entire file.  Apparently, Mr. Djmal began his odyssey by posing as a realtor and telling FDOT that he had a "client interested in purchasing the parcel." [source: email dated October 7, 2013].

From that point on Djmal's "client" disappeared, and on October 9, 2013 Djmal wrote Vince Reuben (FDOT Property Management Administrator): "It is difficult to explain on an email why we would be willing go to [sic] this extent just for a small parcel of land, but it has to do with the interest some people like myself have in remaining in the neighborhood and be close to our loved ones  There is not much land available to live in skylake ..."

Well, not much land maybe, but plenty of existing homes to buy and renovate!

On the same day (10/9/2013), one of the FDOT Engineers had written in a letter in the file "I consider that the triangular vacant land serves as retention when heavy rainstorm events occur in the area, which eventually discharges to the wet pond.  I would not take the risk of selling this vacant land."

This was a hurdle, but not an insurmountable one.  From the FDOT's file summary notes: "After several months going back in fourth [sic!] Drainage agreed to not have an objection as long Applicant [sic] complies w/ several stipulations addressed on surplus comments."

So Djmal had convinced FDOT to sell him the land, but for what price?  Well, FDOT apparently asked the proposed BUYER to tell them the price.  This is where things get a little astounding. Imagine you are shopping for a house, and you go to a showing and like what you see, and when you ask the price, the seller tells you to go and get an appraisal and tell THEM what the price is.  So in those circumstances, wouldn't you, as the person PAYING the appraiser, expect them to appraise the property for the lowest amount possible?  Most reasonable people would, but not the FDOT.

Let's stop here for a second to consider this:  If you are reading this post and live "West of Aventura", what do you think the size of your parcel is?  If it's a 50x100' lot, it would be .11 acres.  A 100x100' lot is .23 acres, and there are not many lots that large in our area.  So most of us live on less than 1/4 acre.  Next, consider what you think the value of that land is.  There have been plenty of tear-down houses sold in the area the last few years, and even a home in the worst possible shape is worth about $300K.  So, if a 1/4 acre lot is worth about $300K, then a parcel 1.65 acres in size (over SIX 1/4 lots) should be worth about 6 x $300K, right?  That's $1,800,000.

So FDOT, our State government, should have pocketed a decent amount of money, to fix our roads and highways, and make those horrible express lanes safer, right?  They would have posted notices on the property announcing its sale, right?  They would have sold it in an open and public process, correct?

No, No and No.

Djmal, who to his credit is no idiot, got his appraiser (Callaway & Price, Inc.), to prepare an estimate of the 1.65 acre parcel, and in their seasoned and "unbiased" opinion, "the Market Value of the Fee Simple Estate of the Subject Property as of June 25, 2014 was: $165,000".  That's $165,000 for SIX, virgin, 1/4 acre lots surrounded by some of the most valuable enclaves in our community: Coventry, Oak Hammock, Chateaux, where a vacant lot would probably we worth much more than the $300,000 I cited earlier - more like $500K++.

FDOT posted ONE notice of sale, and here it is:

Just a tiny little ad in a publication most of you probably never even heard of.  Published only ONE day, and ZERO signs posted on the property itself, and no onsite auction.

So it shouldn't be surprising to hear how many people showed up to bid at the auction: just one - Mr. Djmal.  On January 26, 2015 at 10:00am in a Conference Room at the FDOT, a single sealed bid was opened, and the winning bid was $255,000.  Six 1/4 acre vacant lots for the price of one, or what I call it (as a local expert in realty sales): "The Steal of the Century."

The winner?: Djmal is said to be in talks with Chateau to expand that development onto this parcel.  He will make millions.  Apparently just as he had no "client" in his introduction to FDOT, he also has no "loved ones unable to find homes in Skylake," and will just have to settle for anyone else willing to plunk $1-2M for one of the mansions that will soon populate the 1.65 acres.

The losers?: Anyone who drives a car in the State of Florida - FDOT did us all a disservice by failing to hold a well-publicized and open sale.  Need proof?: how many people in our area would have paid more than $255,000 for a 1.65 acre lot?!  I know I would have begged, borrowed and stole to have the kind of opportunity I could retire on, for a multiple of $255,000.



Friday, November 17, 2017

Rail Improvements are Complete, so Where's the Peace and Quiet?

The road closures in our area this year were a mess.  In April 2017 I started getting lots of communications from Highland Oaks Middle school that Miami Gardens Drive ("MGD") was going to experience a disruptive closure.  As it turned out, that was "fake news" as Brightline (the operator of All Aboard Florida ("AAF")) had in fact postponed that work to everyone's great relief.  All indications were that the work would be completed in the summer.

On May 12 I wrote Ms. Ali Soule (Director of Public Affairs for AAF): 
"Keep in mind that schools resume on Monday, August 21.  If you are targeting "late July or early August" for MGD, that should work perfectly, but things will become very crazy on August 21, so hopefully MGD will be completed before then."

On July 6 I followed up with her for an update.  She wrote back the same day "Hi, Mark. We are still working on our schedule. I should have a better idea next week and will follow up with you. Thanks!"

On July 23 I wrote Ali: "Still no word on MGD improvements?  First day of school is just 29 days away."  Her reply the next day: "Mark, our schedule has shifted, and we will not be able to complete MGD before school begins. I will let you know when it has been put on the schedule. Thanks." 

The result, we all now know, was that MGD was closed, for some unknown reason many surrounding roads like WDH were also closed, and it was a cluster-f.  

The "light at the end of the tunnel" though was that the train horns would stop going off all night, right?  

The establishment of a "Quiet Zone" is described in the Federal Railway Administration's "Horn and Quiet Zone Fact Sheet".  That sheet describes how the affected government (MDC in this case) drives the process, and the Miami Herald reported (here) that it was the County's Transportation Planning Organization ("TPO") specifically that owned the issue.  

... Which is why I was confused when I spoke with TPO's Intergovernmental Affairs Coordinator Bradley Woodson to ask where things stood on the Quiet Zone now that (in November) the crossing improvements were now complete.  I was confused because Woodson advised me that he didn't "have any concrete information at the moment. All I’m able to tell you for now is that the quiet zones are still in the project, but as of the status, it would have to come from Mr. Lefevre [Operations Control Center Director for AAF]".

So even though a Quiet Zone is established by a government, here the government was directing me to the train operator.  Strange.  

So moving on to Mr. Lefevre, I was advised: "the additional signal equipment required for the quiet zone is being installed as part of the AAF construction project, which is why the timing of AAF’s service start and the quiet zone establishment are correlated.... Service into Miami will begin in the first quarter of 2018. There is a mandatory 21-day period between filing the Notice of Establishment and the effective date of the quiet zone, and there is a process of application and inspection to go through with the Federal Railroad Administration, but we are working collaboratively with the MPO and Miami-Dade County on this process."

So when will those of us here in the east part of "West of Aventura" be able to open our windows at night for some fresh air and NO train horn noise at all hours?  The answer is still blowing (a train horn) in the wind.

Friday, April 28, 2017

Development GOLD RUSH "East of West of Aventura"

Subtitle: what is going on with West Dixie Highway ("WDH") between Miami Gardens and Ives Dairy?

There was a good start to answering this burning question 3 years ago (here, in case you were interested), but because I cleaned up my google drive, not realizing the pictures there needed to exist to show up in this blog, it (and many earlier posts) got a little decimated.

So let's do a little "re-inventing of the wheel" and see who the big parcel owners are on WDH, and what we know of their plans.

Part 1: Here's a picture where Aventura Mall is recognizable on the right side, and Ives Dairy Road is the yellow line running along the top.  The 2 vertical yellow lines are US1 and WDH, running parallel to each other, with the rail road tracks not visible, but sandwiched in between.


So beginning at the top (just below Ives Dairy, and just left of the yellow line on the left which is WDH), you have the new Beacon Tower, which you all know and recognize, and you can find all about at http://beacontoweraventura.com.  

Next, as we move south, is the huge former trailer-park parcel that is now the site of "Gables Aventura" which was pretty thoroughly analyzed in my May 12, 2004 post.  It consists of hundreds of rental apartments, which means hundreds of new car-driving residents moving in this year.  There's much more info on the development than there was in 2004, and the best place to research is https://www.gables.com/communities/florida/aventura/gables-aventura/.


Next comes 19800 West Dixie Highway, a 122,068 sf parcel owned by “Eliahu Ben Shmuel Trust, and Daniel Mims Ben Shmuel Trust.”  I covered this in an older post, but to repeat myself: The owner address is in Tennessee, but Eliahu Ben-Shmuel is a businessman in his 70s living in Golden Beach, who previously founded Swiss Watch International (a Florida-based company that “designs and makes timepieces worldwide,” including counterfeiting Seiko and Pulsar watches, according to this 2002 case).  SWI was started by Eliahu (“Eli”) in 1995, but was later run by his 3 sons Izac (42), Lior (40) and Shlomi (36) [source], before being sold in late 2012.  This parcel was purchased (together with the others described below) for $3.4M in December 2012.


19790 WDH was owned by March Property Acquisitions LLC when I wrote the posts in 2004, but now it's owned by "WD 19790 LLC", who bought it in February 2015 for $2.375M (which means it was flipped pretty quickly by March Properties who bought it in September 2013 for $1.25M).  The the new owner has very big plans, as anyone would know who has seen the massive tower dominating the eastern horizon: "The Forum Aventura" (which like many "Aventura" buildings is NOT in Aventura).  Tons of info in the sales brochure: http://x.lnimg.com/attachments/D2B0B69E-BC9F-43C7-BEF2-D69EBB7BEFFD.pdf (be sure to note all the hilarious references to Aventura, keeping in mind that the building is not in Aventura).

Next is 19770 owned, again, but the Ben-Shmuel trusts.  This 54,014sf parcel was purchased (together with other parcels) for $3.4M in December 2012.

Then 19680, a 49,223 sf parcel also owned by the Ben-Shmuel trusts, and part of the $3.4M deal in December 2012.

19640 WDH is owned by "CK Prive Group 196 LLC", which bought it for $8.5M in 2016.  It's a larger, rectangular 95,832sf parcel.  Since this owner is behind the "Forum Aventura" building (see story at http://www.bizjournals.com/southflorida/news/2016/09/08/office-condo-project-near-major-mall-breaks-ground.html), I believe that this and the parcels from 19640 up to 19790 are all combined to accommodate Forum Aventura.

And last up in Part 1 (which ends at 195th Street), is 19580 WDH, is the "L" shaped parcel Owned by Waterford I Associates LTD (2100 Hollywood Blvd), which itself is owned by CORNERSTONE WATERFORD, which is then owned by "JL Holding Corp (managed by Jorge Lopez), M3 Assets (Managed by Leon & Lisa Wolfe), and M.S. Mades Family Limited Partnership (Managed by a company managed by Mara Mades).  Don't know any of these people, but they're all richer than me obviously, and the ownership web is very complex.

Oh yeah: that building surrounded by the "L" is the "U-Store It" building, purchased in 2011 for $13.5M.  


Part 2: South of NE 195th

The "Miron" building at 19400 WDH: When I moved to the area at the turn of the century, I made a lot of runs to this nearby hardware store.  I thought it would be a great place to put a brew-pub, but I'm too busy writing stupid blogs to start the next "Funky Buddha".  Anyway, it was sold as part of a bankruptcy for $3.8M in 2013 to "194 W Dixie Holdings LLC" (another really original name), which is owned by Yonel Fellous and Nathan Cohen, described as "very successful real estate agents, selling super high-end condos in Miami" in an article you will find here.  That same article describes a company called "MODANI" in the high-end furniture business, especially this excerpt: "Modani boasts 10 showrooms in the United States and Canada. They have plans to open 15 more over the next two years. Modani’s latest opening—in Aventura, Florida—is a sprawling 60,000-square-foot space. The state-of-the-art showroom incorporates cutting-edge technology that enables buyers to digitally insert furniture into 3D models of their spaces."

South of the bend in the road is the fenced up mess at 19301: 117,544 square feet of who knows-what owned by "19301 West Dixie Storage LLC" (in other words, someone is parking on the land waiting for things to turn it around and make them rich).

South of that, on the right (east) side is the Telephone building owned by "So Bell Tel & Tel Co", which has been there so long, there's not even any sales data available.  

And the last biggie (outlined in yellow in the picture above) is 2681 NE 191st Street (for some reason it has no WDH street address).  This large 211,662sf parcel was bought in 2014 for $7.43M by "WD 2600 LLC", which is managed by Alberto, Jacobo and Shlomo Kamhazi.  

Then the parcels get smaller and a little less interesting.  There is a sad little park that is all the "green space" the area will likely ever see, and a post office that I hope stays open (not a zoo like the one in Hallandale or the one across from Lorenzo's market).

At the bottom of the picture, on the WEST side of WDH, there are 2 empty parcels.  These are 18802, and 18820 WDH, which are newsworthy, because on May 10 there will be a public hearing at the Highlands Oak Park building to discuss a variance being sought for these parcels.  From an HOA Board member:
On May 10th, there will be a Zoning Appeals Board meeting at the Highland Oaks Park Building where two development plans will be presented both asking for Non-Use Variances (for height increases).  The current zoning laws allow for a maximum height of 6 stories and one proposed plan is requesting a variance to increase up to 9 and 12 stories and the other proposed plan is requesting a variance to 8 stories.  The addresses for the proposed plans are 2681 NE 191 St. and 18802-18820 West Dixie Highway, respectively.  

The 2 parcels are owned by "Aventura Square LLC", and are directly across the street from 18801, which is being developed as described in this recent post.  I feel bad for the students at Ojus Elementary School (NW corner of WDH and Miami Gardens Drive): not only are they going to have a lot more trains passing by in the future, they're also in the vortex of a development hurricane that our unincorporated community has little power over.

The other big unanswered question: is a commuter rail station going to be possible given all this development, or are developers scrambling to construct massive high rises on every parcel, as a poison pill to protect against "eminent domain"?  This is why this strip is in desperate need of community oversight, especially in the absence of any local government.  

Attend zoning hearings!




Aventura Mall is in a low-income community?!?!

Not much to write about lately: either I'm busy with real work, or just less cranky.   Aww, you KNOW I'm no less cranky! But even...